KarMel Scholarship 2008

 

Editorial

“We Should be Past Applauding”

By Raymond Ceo

 

 

Desciption of Submission: Editorial about J.K. Rowling announcing that Harry Potter character Albus Dumbledore is gay.” - Ray

 

 

 

J.K. Rowling, the author of the popular Harry Potter series, just announced that one of her most prominent characters, Albus Dumbledore, is gay.

According to the BBC News Article published on Saturday Oct. 20, J.K. Rowling was answering questions to her fans, and some kid asked her if Dumbledore ever found "true love." She replied by explaining that she always thought he was gay.

Since this announcement, dozens of articles have circulated regarding Rowling and Dumbledore, and personally, I know the countdown has just begun on why Harry Potter should not be allowed in schools, or in young reader's hands due to homosexual content.

Yes, the Harry Potter books have enjoyed plenty of censorship and what the American Library Association calls "challenges" (where someone would like that book removed from the library shelves; the actual outcome varies,) however the banning of Harry Potter was usually focused on anti-Christian values, specifically witchcraft and fantasy.

Now, the ballgame of why this popular series should be burned is different. We are no longer discussing witchcraft and fantasy, but instead we are talking about a much more taboo subject: gay love.

Examples of this are tragically embedded in our history. In 1895 the famous playwright/poet, Oscar Wilde, was found guilty for "gross indecency" for his homoerotic themes found in his only novel "The Picture of Dorian Gray." When I visited Auschwitz this summer, it was not until I saw the upside-down pink triangle that homosexuals had to wear on their arms that I fell to pieces. It is disgusting how far humans will go to make their own agendas a reality.

And it is somewhat scary to think that if I lived in the 1890's to the 1940's, I could be prosecuted and eventually killed for being gay.

But, honestly, not much has changed, and because of this it is not just our history that we should be alarmed about. Instead, we should fight the intolerance of gay love today.

In 2006, for instance, the short children's book called "And Tango Makes Three" was on top of the "Most Challenged" list, says the American Library Association. It is a cute story, about two penguins who are best friends. Together they form a union, and find a rock. They take turns sitting on this rock, and wait for it to hatch, to no avail. Finally, one of the zoo keepers gives them an egg, and they properly birth and raise a child, named Tango. This true story is based on a gay penguin couple from the New York City Zoo. Second on the list of banned books for 2006 is the popular young adult novel called "Gossip Girls", again for its homosexual themes.

Since JK Rowling's announcement last Friday about our beloved headmaster being a queer, she has been applauded for pushing gay rights. But she hasn't done this. Instead, she just wrote life and how it is. It is damn near impossible to not know a gay person, when, according to almost every credible source, at least one in ten are gay, in fact, there is an organization under that same name.

Because there are so many homosexuals in this world, having a character being homosexual is not too uncommon. In fact, statistically speaking, there should be more. What I am most happy about, at least for JK Rowling's sake, is that this "outing" of Dumbledore will be a battle she will now have to face every single time she goes to get her books signed. She has opened up a dialogue to help people understand homosexuality.

And, personally, it was not until literally an hour ago (when one of my teachers called homosexuality a preference) did I think people need to be further educated about homosexuality. I often thought it was simply just closed minded idiots who believed homosexuality is a choice, especially when prestigious entities such as UCLA and the U.S. National Institute of Health run separate studies that find that homosexuality is genetic.

With all of the research and facts that keep going into why we are gay, we should be past the day that J.K. Rowling, or anyone for that matter, is applauded for including real, honest to life love, whether it be gay or straight love, in their novels, because, honestly, there is no difference.

 

 

 

 

Back